IDP Position Determination

[The Immortal Ramirez]

I think DL, LB, DB

[Flaxwless]

DL, LB, CB 2 of each, with 1 back up for each position.

I would be open to a flex, i don't care as I have never participated in an IDP league.

[Preds]

Originally Posted by The Immortal Ramirez

I think DL, LB, CB

I think you mean DL, LB, DB (not CB).

Anyhow, we should define DL as DT, DE or NT

LB's are straightup just LB's

and DB's are CB's, Free Safeties, Strong Safeties, Nicke Backs, Dime Backs

Sounds good to me.

I would probably vote for 2/2/2 with 6 additional bench added.

[The Immortal Ramirez]

Sorry for the typo...I corrected it.
I agree with definitions of the positions and agree with what Mike (Preds) wrote.
I think we can do 12 IDP (6 active, 6 reserve)

The previous IDP league I played in was ANY 3 IDP. Some fools put in Warran Sapp and Michael Strahan because of name-sake. However, production-wise they don't compare to LBs or DBs. So, I like having to have at least one of each.

[keepers]

6 starting IDPs, 2 each of DLs, LBs and DBs sound good.

I vote not to have a restriction on how many have to have at a position and offensive vs defensive players, but am fine if we decide to.

Originally Posted by The Immortal Ramirez

Sorry for the typo...I corrected it.
I agree with definitions of the positions and agree with what Mike (Preds) wrote.
I think we can do 12 IDP (6 active, 6 reserve)

The previous IDP league I played in was ANY 3 IDP. Some fools put in Warran Sapp and Michael Strahan because of name-sake. However, production-wise they don't compare to LBs or DBs. So, I like having to have at least one of each.

That is what you get when you play yahoo leagues with guppies :box

[Nittany Dodgers]

Six starters (2 of each) seems to be the consensus. I'm also for 2 reserves for each. Only one reserve requires quite the planning ahead for byes, and kills you on injuries.

[The Immortal Ramirez]

Don't get me started on your IDP knowledge, Skippy...

[The Immortal Ramirez]

Dodgers... good point. for first year, we should have at least two of each. we can always change it next year.

[Burt the Butcher]

Originally Posted by Preds

I think you mean DL, LB, DB (not CB).

Anyhow, we should define DL as DT, DE or NT

LB's are straightup just LB's

and DB's are CB's, Free Safeties, Strong Safeties, Nicke Backs, Dime Backs

This works best, based on my experience with IDP's. One league breaks out CB's from Safties, and it's a nightmare unless you have all rosters memorized.

[The Immortal Ramirez]

Vote:

Starters: 6 ( 2 DL - DT, DE, NT: 2 LB - all: 2 DB - safeties, CB, nickel, dime any other backfield dude)
Bench: 6 (whatever order you want - or can afford)

Vote so far:

Preds - yah
Skippy - yah
Keepers - yah
Dodgers - yah
Paulsonpatch - yah
Ramirez - yah

No nays, yet.

We need one more vote to make this formal...and put it to rest

[Preds]

Originally Posted by The Immortal Ramirez

Vote:

Starters: 6 ( 2 DL - DT, DE, NT: 2 LB - all: 2 DB - safeties, CB, nickel, dime any other backfield dude)
Bench: 6 (whatever order you want - or can afford)

Vote so far:

Preds - yah
Skippy - yah
Keepers - yah
Dodgers - yah
Paulsonpatch - yah
Ramirez - yah

No nays, yet.

We need one more vote to make this formal...and put it to rest

Rami, just setup a Poll (new thread)... easier to track the vote

[The Immortal Ramirez]

Vote:

Starters: 6 ( 2 DL - DT, DE, NT: 2 LB - all: 2 DB - safeties, CB, nickel, dime any other backfield dude)
Bench: 6 (whatever order you want - or can afford)

Vote so far:

Preds - yah
Skippy - yah
Keepers - yah
Dodgers - yah
Paulsonpatch - yah
Ramirez - yah

No nays, yet.

We need one more vote to make this formal...and put it to rest

[Valencia]

yah... make it formal

[Valencia]

Yah... I will try it again here... your confusing me.. BTW... that doesn't take much. :wow

[The Immortal Ramirez]

mikey made me put it here...I wanted to keep it in the other thread.

Thanks, though, now we can go after some of the other points.

[Preds]

Originally Posted by The Immortal Ramirez

Vote:

Starters: 6 ( 2 DL - DT, DE, NT: 2 LB - all: 2 DB - safeties, CB, nickel, dime any other backfield dude)
Bench: 6 (whatever order you want - or can afford)

Vote so far:

Preds - yah
Skippy - yah
Keepers - yah
Dodgers - yah
Paulsonpatch - yah
Ramirez - yah

No nays, yet.

We need one more vote to make this formal...and put it to rest

I said create a POLL Rami! Do I HAVE to walk you through it? What am I talking to Skip? ;)

There's a check box below the message box to create a poll. Once you post the thread it will take you to another screen to create the poll that will be part of the thread.

Then everybody votes (anonymously) with the poll showing where the voting stands.

[The Immortal Ramirez]

I have never done a poll...hmmm, fascinating. Tell me more. Orrrrr, Mr Fancy-pants, you could have set it up yourself instead of mocking my lack of knowledge of the board!

I will let you crude, rude and barbaricly snide comment slide this time....

[The Immortal Ramirez]

by the way, the only 'check box' I have below this message box says "Quote message in reply?" That's it. Nothing about poll.

The check box is when you are posting a new thread you say make this thread a poll.

[The Immortal Ramirez]

ahhhhhh. never looked there.

[Philadelphia Freedom]

I am good here.

[Mutts]

Originally Posted by The Immortal Ramirez

Vote:

Starters: 6 ( 2 DL - DT, DE, NT: 2 LB - all: 2 DB - safeties, CB, nickel, dime any other backfield dude)
Bench: 6 (whatever order you want - or can afford)

Vote so far:

Preds - yah
Skippy - yah
Keepers - yah
Dodgers - yah
Paulsonpatch - yah
Ramirez - yah

No nays, yet.

We need one more vote to make this formal...and put it to rest

Works for me.

[Liquid Swords]

good

[The Immortal Ramirez]

Originally Posted by The Immortal Ramirez

Vote:

Starters: 6 ( 2 DL - DT, DE, NT: 2 LB - all: 2 DB - safeties, CB, nickel, dime any other backfield dude)
Bench: 6 (whatever order you want - or can afford)

Once again, powers that be say we must formally have a secret ballor vote in poll format. Please vote for or against at the top...sorry for the repeated work -- you didn't want to get any real work done on Friday anyway!:bitch

[Nittany Dodgers]

Originally Posted by The Immortal Ramirez

Once again, powers that be say...

You'll learn the "powers that be" from the Frenzy can be a little anal. Just look at the rule book for verification.

looks like another vote that can close.