Quote:
Originally Posted by Burt the Butcher
Well, there are other ways of course, opinions of whether they are better will vary obviously.
Say you lost a single 1st round tender and he was 300cb over tender amount.
I lost two 3rd rounder and a 4th rounder, and my overage totaled 400cb.
we both get 2nd round comps, but I get higher pick, even I theoretically lost way more value than you did. Seems unfair for 1st pick, even more so each subsequent round if we both had multiple picks
|
Who's to say the reason team B had more CB's over tender wasn't because he didn't intentionally under tender a player or players?
There is no perfect system, however, when the rules were originally written it was when comp was on a per player basis, not points. With the point system it's really not possible to award the pick selection by the tender difference on 1 player since it's possible to combine 2, even 3 RFA losses into 1 comp pick.
I think awarding the picks based on the totals over the tender per team, and adjusting for subsequent rounds for teams who haven't already received a comp pick (ex the Burners in rd 3, and possibly the Dogs should they decline to match Gates) is as fare as it gets.